The cold weather of late-autumn and winter months is, without a doubt, my favorite time of year. But for a lot of us in our living situations, the cold weather brings up some hard questions that nobody can agree on the answer to…
Now, disagreements about the thermostat will happen throughout your life. It will start with your family, with your dad guarding the thermostat with his life (or whichever of your parents are the most cost-conscious).
Then when you move out of the house, you'll have disagreements with your roommates over who is running what heat or AC and when, and who should be paying for it. Finally, you'll have these same spats with your spouse… and let's be honest, you probably still have roommates in the mix too, especially if you're under the age of 35.
Oh, and there's still plenty of time for the temperature of the office at work to be a big workplace issue too!
These disagreements tend to revolve around three things:
- What temperature can you personally tolerate?
- This can be different and even change for a number of reasons due to factors like age, genetics, gender, and personal preference.
(Everyone is unique in this regard, and that's a wonderful thing… until it comes to the fact that the thermostat only has one setting…)
- This can be different and even change for a number of reasons due to factors like age, genetics, gender, and personal preference.
- What clothes do you like to wear?
- Are shorts and T-shirts your go-to? Or do you look forward to breaking out the comfy sweatshirts and sweatpants and even thermal base layers every winter?
- What is the cost? (and who is paying?)
- Different people are more or less sensitive to the cost required to meet their desired temperature. And this will shape their preference too.
A person reads a book while holding a ceramic mug beneath a yellow blanket, staying warm inside thanks to layers despite the cold weather.
Licensed media supplied as editorial context.
For this couple, it was much the same as it is for the rest of us… But for them specifically, it seems their disagreement comes from what is purely a difference in preference for what clothes they like to wear at home:
She wants to embrace the cozy vibes of the season, whereas he wants to lounge in shorts and a T-shirt. And his desire to be comfortable without all the layers is incompatible with her seasonal aesthetic.
I've definitely had this conversation with my partner (more than) a few times.
Sound familiar to anyone else?
"A or B: In winter, do you keep the heat low and wear a sweater, or turn it up and walk around in a t-shirt?"
A young woman wrapped in a blanket sits on a sofa.
The girlfriend shared her experience on this subreddit, appealing to readers for their votes on which direction they should take with their heating disagreement.
In her account of events, she outlined the seasonal disagreement as it occurs annually:
It finally got cold, and my boyfriend and I are back to fighting over the thermostat. I keep it at 68. I put on a hoodie and thick socks and I'm fine. The gas bill is lower too. He gets home from work, turns it up to 72, and changes into shorts and a t-shirt.
Story Source: BedPast5236 via Reddit
A person wrapped in a thick blanket holds an open book and a mug, embracing the cozy weather.
Featured likenesses do not identify those mentioned.
His argument was that she shouldn't have the heat on at all if she was still going to use a blanket.
I was on the couch under a blanket, and he was walking around barefoot. He looked at me and said, "What's the point of having the heat on if you still need a blanket?"
But let's be real, there is a difference between taking the edge off a bit by turning the heat on and having to wear cold-weather thermal base layers under what you have on already.
She says the same conversation comes up every winter; she would rather not run the heat at all and pile on more and more clothes, whereas he just wants to relax in his shorts and T-shirt.
We have this same talk every winter. I don't think either of us is wrong. I'd rather just put on more clothes.
He wants to come home and not have to think about it. What do you keep yours at?
A person wearing grey sweats and wool socks rests on a white bed with an open book and mug.
Representative only.
This ever-relatable situation, of course, would have kicked off a lot of discussion in the comments regardless, but in keeping with the spirit of this particular subreddit community, she gave readers two options to pick between “A” or “B”, readers can of course submit a proposal of their own as “C."
So which is it?
Her preference:
A. Around 68 and wear a sweater. I'd rather put on more layers than heat the whole house.
Or, his preference:
B. Turn it up. I want to be comfortable in my own house without bundling up.
A pug wrapped in a blanket, representing all of us when we feel cold at home. (Look at him isn't he cute?)
The scene shown is a visual representation.
For me personally, I am built for cold: physically and genetically.
I'm sure that the advertising bots building a profile on me are going to love me writing this… But my ancestry is basically just Scottish, Norwegian, English, and Pacific Northwest Native American. The most "heat tolerant" genealogy in that list is probably the English… and ask any Brit—that's not saying much.
(This is, of course, my own personal opinion and speculation for fun and by no means an exact science of any kind.)
Beyond that, I've got a solid build, and I run pretty hot. My ideal temperature is 60-65 degrees Fahrenheit; I can sit pretty comfortably, not active, at that temperature in shorts and a T-shirt. Honestly, if it gets above 70, I am sweating. And at 80+, I don't want to be there.
My spouse, on the other hand, well, she's pretty sensitive to cold, so you can imagine how that conversation goes in our household. In the summer, I want the AC blasting so that I can live in a refrigerator, which she can't tolerate. And in the winter, I'm sitting there saying, "Don't touch the thermostat," in shorts and a T-Shirt while she's freezing in sweatpants and a fleece.
This is really tricky in office buildings too, which are normally way too warm or way too cold depending on what the thermostat, or central heating for the entire building, is set to.
You might walk to work in the winter, freezing the entire way, only to roast once you get indoors because the heater is doing too much work. On the flip side, you might have to bring a sweater to the office with you in the summer because, while it's roasting outside, it's way too artificially cold once you sit down at your desk, and your fingers are freezing so bad you can't type. (I haven't personally experienced this, but I am assured that it is a thing by my colleagues.)
A man relaxes on the sofa in a T-shirt and shorts with his dog, sharing a moment of downtime together.
Stock image; this is simply how I imagine her boyfriend wanting to chill on the couch in his shorts and T-shirt, as I do
So what did readers have to say?
Well, this one was definitely more split than we have seen in r/PickAorB posts, showing how varied personal preferences are when it comes to heating… and just how contentious the issue is!
Of the on-topic responses that I tallied, 93 responders voted “A. Keep the heat low and add layers if needed,” whereas 20 responses voted “B. Turn up the heat for comfort,” and 27 voted “C. Other or conditional preferences” or offered some other alternative, including setting the temperature to a midpoint or heating individual rooms.
That puts us at about:
A. Keep the heat low and add layers if needed: ~66% of responses
B. Turn up the heat for comfort: ~14% of responses
C. Other or conditional preferences, including a midpoint or heating individual rooms: ~20% of responses
So, while the vote was more split, there is still a clear favorite here… and I guess it makes sense. While you can always put more layers on, there is a limit to the number of layers you can take off; at least that's the argument I always make to my spouse when she is freezing, and I am roasting already!
But that's enough from me on this one. What's your take? Take a look at the key discussion points below, where the original poster was quite active in the discussion and responded to a lot of commenters.
Then, after, let me know your thoughts.
The Responses
This was the top comment, suggesting that they like some others I have spoken to about this and can't tolerate the cold air.
The original poster responded here that this comment had caused her to reflect further on the issue:
This commenter thought that the boyfriend should just put more layers on himself.
The original poster responded here too:
Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.